FanEx Analysis Draft
Review | Rules | Transactions

Round 9



Draft Rounds
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16

  9.01 (via O'Leary trade)
RB Stacey Mack

QB: McNair Green RB Hearst Rhodes Dayne Mack WR Moss Owens  TE: Gonzalez PK: DT:
Kellogg
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.02 (via Cannon trade)
TE Freddie Jones

QB: Griese RB: Dillon Thomas 
Henry Barlow
WR: KeyJohnson Chambers TE: Jones PK: DT:
Kadlec
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.03 (via KFFL trade)
TE Chad Lewis

QB: Vick Plummer RB: Williams Taylor Garner WR: RSmith TrBrown Morton TE: Lewis  PK: DT:
Dolfi
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.04 (via Dodds trade)
QB Tim Couch 

QB: Garcia Couch RB: Martin Lewis Foster JAllen WR: Horn Glenn 
Gardner Ward
TE: PK: DT:
Cahill
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.05 (via KFFL trade)
QB Trent Dilfer

QB McNabb Dilfer RB: Holmes George Pittman WR: TBrown Booker Ismail TE: Sharpe PK: DT:

Holm
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.06
TE Ernie Conwell

QB Culpepper RB: James Staley Dunn Wheatley WR: Bruce Thrash Muhammad TE: Conwell  PK: DT:
Hickerson
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.07
RB Rickey Watters

QB: Brooks RB: Tomlinson SDavis LSmith Alstott Watters 
 
WR: Jackson KevJohnson Alexander TE: PK: DT:
Hansen
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.08
WR Travis Taylor

QB: Manning Brady RB: ESmith Green Barber   WR: Harrison Conway Taylor TE: Franks  PK: DT:
Rito
Panizo
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.09 (via Kellogg trade)
WR Joey Galloway

QB: Favre  Bledsoe RB :Faulk  ASmith Jones WR: Mason Toomer Galloway TE: Wycheck  PK: DT:
O'Leary
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.10 (via Cahill trade)
QB Mark Brunnell

QB: Stewart Fiedler Brunnell
RB: Alexander McAllister 
Stewart WR :Holt JSmith McCaffrey  
TE: PK: DT:
Dodds
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.11 (via Holm trade)
WR Peerless Price

QB: Gannon Collins  RB: Green 
Bettis Duckett
WR: Boston Rice Price TE: Pollard PK: DT:
Del Pilar
Bonini
Analysis
Guest
Analysis
  9.12
WR Koren Robinson

QB: Griese RB: Dillon Thomas 
Henry Barlow
WR: KeyJohnson Chambers Robinson TE: Jones 
PK  DT:
Kadlec
Analysis
Guest
Analysis

Draft Rounds
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16


9.01 RB Stacey Mack

By
Greg Kellogg of Komments

I felt it imperative I move ahead of Mr. Hickerson to grab the player, I felt he would grab last round.  Following a trade, I claim RB Stacey Mack gives me a player that gained over 1000 total yards and scored 10 TDs last year as a part-time starter.

He even averaged over 4 YPC as Fred Taylor's replacement.  This is the ultimate boom or bust selection.  If Taylor stays healthy for the entire season (sic), Mack will only get limited opportunities and was a waste of roster space. 

However, should Taylor once again suffer injury, Stacey Mack just may be my best RB.  With Mack on board, my four RBs averaged 1,183 Total Yards and 8 TDs last year - all have question marks entering this season, but if just two of them play up to a year ago, I should be fine in my backfield.


9.01 RB Stacey Mack

By Guest Paul Rush
You don't really expect much in the 9th round and selecting a backup RB with a girls name doesn't sound too promising !
 
However,  this particular Stacey certainly showed he could play the game last season with over 1000 combined yards and 10 TDs for the Jags. The question is will he get the chance to repeat those numbers this season ?
 
Well the good news for Mr. Kellogg is that he's backing up the extremely talented but rather fragile Fred Taylor who has missed nearly 50% of regular games over the last three seasons (23 out of 48), including 14 last season. It's an odds on bet that a trivial injury such as an ingrown toenail or a blister on his little finger may become season ending for this guy which means Mack could easily end up being quite a valuable guy.
 
A pick with plenty of upside.


9.01 RB Stacey Mack

By Guest Mark Horan


After defying convention and incurring the wrath of RB-crazies like myself, Greg continues to use the later rounds of the draft to stack his roster with young RBs with upside. After a solid season replacing the ever injured Freddie T, RB Stacey Mack certainly fits that profile.

Greg's strategy is high risk, but potentially also high reward. Building your backfield on the hopes of injury to other players is extremely risky, but if you were to predict injury, Terrell Davis and Taylor would be the two guys you would look at first. Even Freddie T usually gets a handful of games in before he goes down, though, which could put Greg in a hole early in league competition. While I think it's a reach to describe this RB collection as "fine," if Freddie or Edge goes down again, this team will be very dangerous. If Greg can hang around early, he could be poised for a serious late season push at a title. Conversely, if Freddie and Edge stay healthy, with Moss/Owens at WR, McNair/Green at QB, and Gonzales at TE, picking up a quality RB via trade is also an option.  


9.01 RB Stacey Mack

By Guest Deb DuBois of Fantasy Insights

RB Stacey Mack in the 9th round? Wow. This is really a good pick.  He proved himself in 2000 by stepping up when Fred Taylor was injured and although he was hurt last year with that finger injury, he will be more than ready to compete this year.  Mack makes a great backup to a player that has yet to play a full season, don't be surprised to see it happen again this year.
I find it surprising that he wasn't drafted sooner, but you can bet he will be competing with TAYLOR for the starting job.  Bottom line,  a great pick this late in the draft.

RBs are far and few, well, quality ones are, this guy has the potential to get the job done and has shown in the past he can step up without missing a beat.

9.02 TE Freddie Jones
By Emil Kadlec of FF Pro Forecast

TE Freddie Jones -- who has good size, speed and hands, but who never developed into the consistent performer the Chargers expected -- will step in and try to fill a major hole in Arizona. If nothing else, Jones gives the Cardinals the most talent they've had here in a while, and coaches expect him to be reliable in the run game while providing some balance in the passing game. 

It's also worth noting that Jones played last year for offensive coordinator Norv Turner in a system similar to the Cardinals. Rich Olson, who completed his first season as Cardinals offensive coordinator last year, had been Turner's right-hand man with the Redskins. ... Look for Jones to be an every down player in Arizona with inconsistent incumbent starter Terry Hardy coming off shoulder and knee surgeries. There are no bona fide backups on the roster although converted WR Tywan Mitchell is a receiving threat.

9.02 TE Freddie Jones
By Guest  Mike MacGregor of 
Pro Football Analysis.com

After some yahoo decides to take Tony Gonzalez in the 2nd or 3rd round of your draft, the TE position becomes something of a necessary evil. Most any guy you take is not likely to put your team over the top, but completely ignoring the position all together is troublesome as it puts added pressure on your key position starters to perform. Grabbing a good talent valued about the middle of the pack of TEs is probably the best strategy to implement, and that is just what Emil Kadlec has done here, taking Freddie Jones early in the 9th round as the 7th TE drafted.

Is Jones a good talent? Yes, absolutely. In his 5 seasons with the Chargers he averaged 52 receptions for 586 yards and 3.2 TDs. The fact I am including his rookie season of 41 catches for 505 yards and 2 TDs in the average speaks volumes for Jones' skill. Few TEs kick off their career with that much impact on the stats sheet. Think any of the 6 previously drafted TEs matched Jones' stats in their rookie seasons? Look it up for interest sake, but the answer is no (not even Tony G. or Horse-face).

Now, lets get out of the ancient history and turn a little more into present day. Fortunately, Jones had his best 2 seasons TD-wise in 2000 and 2001, with 5 and 4 respectively. Unfortunately, he had the worst reception and yardage totals of his career in 2001. This is not really a reason for concern though. Jones suffered from an ankle injury, missed 4 games and played hurt through the latter part of the season, causing the decline. These were the first games he missed playing and starting since 1997.

The bigger question mark on Jones heading into the 2002 season is how will he respond to his new environment playing for the perpetually disappointing Cardinals. You may not think much of Jake Plummer throwing Jones the ball, but it really is a modest improvement over most of the QBs Jones has had to deal with in his NFL career in San Diego. I am mildly optimistic about Jones' prospects with the Cards. He isn't about to blow up for 90 catches with David Boston around, but he could easily be the 2nd best receiving option on the team. (Frank Sanders? Puh-lease.) Assuming the Cards use Jones right, 50 to 60 catches is a reasonable expectation which should translate into around 600 yards. The number of TDs is the big swing vote in TE rankings. With that number of projected catches, he should at least have 4 to 5 and potentially more if the coaches like calling his number in the red zone. Early reports indicate the coaches like what they have seen from him.

Final thoughts: The Chargers should have never let Jones go. Fantasy wise Jones will finish higher than the 7th ranked TE and could easily compete for top 3 honors, making him a good value at this draft spot. There looks to be a noticeable drop-off in TE talent after this pick. Through 9 rounds Emil Kadlec is assembling a team to be reckoned with.

9.03 TE Chad Lewis
By Chris Dolfi of FanEx

I traded up the two spots to grab the Philadelphia Eagle I had my eye on... no, not #3 backup RB Rod "He Hate Me" Smart (although I almost want to select him for that XFL jersey alone)... but one of the major cogs in Philadelphia's improving offensive machine - TE Chad Lewis.

Lewis was high on everyone's list last year after posting a 69 catch, 735 yard year in 2000.  In 2001, Lewis seemed to many to slip a little bit by falling to only 41 catches for 422 yards.  But his fantasy performance didn't really fall off that dramatically, as he increased his TDs in 2001 to 6 from his 3 of the previous year.

A legitimate concern fantasy owners might have with Lewis was his disappearance from several games last year, 4 games in which he had a total of less than 10 yards.  Performances like that won't win you many owners hearts.  Lewis scored 2 TDs in 2 games, but one was against the lack-luster Cowboys early in the season before they fully gelled and the other was against the Giants in week 16.  (That concern doesn't mean as much in this scoring system where your best TE will be started for you automatically.)

Although Lewis' performance did seem to drop off last year, I think there were some very positive indications that he will have a bounce-back season in terms of effectiveness. 

Lewis was a target in every single game last year.  In fact, he caught at least 1 pass in every game.  He's still very much a part of the Eagles game plan.  Additionally, quarterback Donovan McNabb is still learning how to play in the NFL.  He was asked to hang in the pocket last year and he did - but didn't always feel the rush coming in time to dump off the ball to his safety valve, Lewis.  He'll get better at it, and Lewis will reap those rewards.

With 2 new receivers in the fold last year (rookie Freddie Mitchell and James Thrash acquired from the Redskins), the Eagles had a TON of three-and-out series which certainly isn't going to help anyone's numbers, and Lewis suffered along with the rest of the offense.  By the end of the year, the Eagles receiving corps was working well together and everyone's numbers jumped up - Lewis included.

Finally, the Eagles really made moves to get Lewis more involved during the play-offs.  He caught 12 passes in 3 play-off games, along with one TD.  The Eagles realize that they are a better team with Lewis involved so I expect to see a commitment to getting Lewis the ball in 2002 as well.

I'm happy to get Lewis as the #7 TE in the draft and fill out the last of my major starting positions.

9.03 TE Chad Lewis

By Guest Erik Sabadie

Dolfi makes a very solid pick, nabbing TE Chad Lewis in round 9.  The Eagles lack a hard-nosed goal line RB, especially with the injury to Buckhalter, so Lewis should get plenty of endzone love this year and easily match or improve on his 6 TDs from last year.  All signs indicate the Eagles offense is on the rise, so you should expect a bump in output from the skill positions.  Consistency from the coaching staff and improvement from the players add up to top-5 TE year for Lewis.

9.04 QB Tim Couch
By Duane Cahill of Pitt Tribune-Review

In perusing the remaining available quarterbacks, I see only three that I would even consider having on my roster as a backup -- Couch, Vinny Testaverde and Trent Dilfer.  I prefer Couch slightly over Dilfer and by far over Vinny.  Two other owners (Hickerson, Hansen) who draft between now and my original 9.10 spot also lack backup quarterbacks, and I wanted to ascertain that I wouldn't be "stuck" with my third choice -- hence the trade.

Why Tim Couch?  First off, there is no Chad Pennington nor Matt Hasselbeck looking over his shoulder.  Barring injury he's guaranteed to start 16 games. 

In examining Couch's career to date, he would appear to be a very pedestrian quarterback.  Last year, he was put into a new offensive system with Bruce Arians (formerly Peyton Manning's QB coach) as his offensive coordinator.  While Couch struggled early in the season, he finished strong, going 76-116 (66%) over the last four games of 2001.  That bodes well for the upcoming year.

In addition, the Browns finally have a bona-fide potential star running back to keep defenses honest and away from the slow-footed quarterback.  Couch was sacked 50 times last year, as many teams could afford to put a linebacker up to spy on him.  The threat of a William Green's size and speed will do significantly more for Couch than James Jackson/Ben Gay/Jamal White could to keep defenders away from Couch last season.

If Couch were to merely equal his 17 TDs from last season, I would be receiving equivalent value to his draft position. 

I suspect with a year in the new offense, a better running game, a better set of receivers (KJ, Quincy Morgan, and the newly signed Chris Sanders) these numbers should improve.  I project 22 TDs and 3200 yards. 

Based on those numbers, I have Couch rated as my 14th QB overall, with a slight dropoff to Dilfer, followed by a significant dropoff.  I felt that it was prudent to make the trade up to get my backup before that drop.

9.04 QB Tim Couch 

By Guest Terry Martin

Everyone pretty much agrees that QB Tim Couch is not a fantasy QB. however his roster value causes mixed reviews. 

I don't see him as the 14th best choice. Perhaps, he's the 24th. Any passer with 5 scores in eleven total games needs to earn my respect prior to his selection. 

Call him a 'promising' or 'upcoming' player. Actually, call him whatever you want. Just don't call his name on draft day.

9.05 QB Trent Dilfer
By Tony Holm of The Prognosticator

I really wanted Tim Couch here but wasn't able to out bid other owners above this selection.  See my trade analysis for more details.

Call me nuts but I've always liked the promise in QB Trent Dilfer.  He has great size with 6-4 and 229 pounds, he was a #6 selection overall in the 1994 draft, has been elected to the Pro Bowl and has led his team into the playoffs. 

Dilfer signed a four-year contract as reward for his play in 2001 with the Seahawks and will be their #1 QB heading into training camp.

Week 16 at San Diego he passed for 267 yards and 3 TDs, good enough to be the 5th best fantasy QB that week.  Week 17 against the Chiefs he passed for 248 yards and 2 TDs which was also the 5th best QB performance of the week.  Once Dilfer was handed the role he started to post great fantasy numbers in this offense.  I deem QB rating one of the best indicators of determining both which direction the player is headed in and how good he is.  Last Yo-Yo season where he was on again off again as the QB in Seattle, he still managed an impressive 92.0 for a QB rating.  Anything over 90 is very good.  I've always wondered what Trent Dilfer could do if he just had receivers, as I think he is one of those guys that takes a lot of knocks for events that are out of his control.  In Tampa Bay he had a running system and garbage for receivers.  With the Ravens the story was much the same.  Seattle is a whole different chapter and holds the potential for a hot bed of statistics.  Darrel!
l Jackson and Koren Robinson are going to be two scary guys to defend this season and Shaun Alexander is going to help get the team to the goal line, where anything can happen. 

Trent Dilfer is looking over his shoulder and with Mike Holmgren I'm never sure of anything as Matt Hasselbeck may gain favorite status because he washed the coaches car again.  But I know I drafted the better QB out of the two, now if Mike Holmgren continues to see it my way, I'll be all set!
 
I really wanted a QB with upside as my #2 to back up Donovan McNabb.  According to my draft list, Trent Dilfer is the last QB available that has shown both the skills and the ambition to be a top QB in the league.  He is in a system that will certainly help him and has a very good supporting cast for the first time in his career.  Trent Dilfer has a lot of upside and very little down.  If he continues to play at the level he finished the 2001 season at, which I fully expect, he will certainly contribute to my FAD team, even with Donovan McNabb.  

9.05 QB Trent Dilfer

By Guest Jym Hansen of Komments.com

I just love Trent Dilfer.  He doesn’t miss many games.  I don’t know many players more competitive.  Leadership is his most admirable quality.  How could you have a problem with Dilfer?

 

If you were awarded points for wins and field leadership, Dilfer would be a top 5 QB.  However, you only get points for yards and TDs, he is not so great.  Trent knows how to win the game and get the job done, but he doesn’t post a ton of stats.  He is the best example of unselfish leadership you can watch.  He will remain around 15-17 overall this season and any season.  He won’t crack the Top 10, but he won’t be in the bottom 10 either.  Don’t expect a huge amount out of Dilfer.

 

As a backup, he is very reliable and consistent.  You won’t see 3 TD games, but you will at least know that you can get something from him.  With McNabb as your starter, you should only need him for one game.  I really like this guy because he is dependable and sturdy.  I don’t like his lack of point production.  You could be in trouble if your starter gets hurt for an extended amount of time.


9.05 QB Trent Dilfer

By Guest Tony
Shek

We all know Dilfer is an unglamorous pick.  Sure, Holmgren wants Hasselblech as his main man and is dying to prove he wasn't a complete waste.  But what are the alternatives to draft?  Brunell, Brad Johnson, Flutie, Testaverde, or Plummer??  Loads of downside to these here, so I believe Dilfer is the way to go, even ahead of Couch.  The advantages of Dilfer:  1.  improved team around him.  2.  Playmakers at the skill slots in Alexander, Koren Robinson, and Darrell Jackson, plus signed Engram who makes a good WR3 and a newly drafted pass catching TE in Stevens.  3.  Coach who loves throwing in the red zone   4.  New division with Arizona, SF, and St Louis.  Definitely has lots of chances to throw or have to throw.  5.  He is a good complement to McNabb who'll do most of the scoring anyways.  At the end of the season where McNabb might be rested, Dilfer gets Atlanta, St Louis, and San Diego.

9.06 TE Ernie Conwell
By Jerome Hickerson of TalkFootball.com
I was hoping for TE Frank Wycheck or Freddie Jones here. Oh well.... I selected Conwell because I don't think it is possible to have too many cogs in the Rams offensive machine. Conwell's 2001 numbers were not stellar but he did finish 11th in our scoring.
 
I'm not a huge fan of making "safe" picks (look at my draft and I think you can see this) but I felt that this was a point where a safe pick was in order. The TE position in FAD can only help you if you get one of the top two or three players. Once those are gone, the key is to make sure to get a player that won't hurt you. In the 9th round, Conwell won't hurt me. And in the explosive offense that he works in, there is plenty of opportunity that his numbers could increase.

9.06 TE Ernie Conwell

By Guest Al Lackner of AskTheCommish.Com

With the 6th pick of the 9th round, Hickerson clearly made a pick of need. With a quality starting QB, a nice looking RB situation, and depth already at WR, Hickerson had to see that TEs are coming off the board in a hurry (2 in the 8th round, and this  is the 3rd of the 9th). He decided to select a TE before the pickings got too slim. The question is, did he select the right TE?

Last year, TE Ernie Conwell benefited from his chance to show what he could do at the TE position without Roland Williams around.  Conwell did not disappoint, as he hauled in 38 catches for 431 yards and 4 TDs in only 14 games.  He scored another TD on the ground as well. 

Those are not bad numbers, and I'll have to say that I really like Conwell as an NFL TE. The trouble is that he may be a better "real" TE than he is a fantasy TE. Indeed, going into the season, I have a hard time seeing him surpass his 2001 numbers. And the 2001 numbers were not good enough to land him in the top ten of fantasy TEs. So I'd be hard pressed to make him the 9th selected TE in this draft.

Had I elected to go the TE route here, I may have been more intrigued by the possibility of the Bills Jay Riemersma or the Saints David Sloan than Conwell. Still, Conwell is a safe pick -- even if it is not necessarily a great value pick.

9.07 RB Rickey Watters
By John Hansen of The Guru Report

Why not?  Even if Watters becomes the next Terry Allen - a RB for hire who gets signed during the season - he's got some serious value as a guy who can step in and out-play at least half the starting backs in the league.  I'm hoping he somehow lands on the Saints because there's no doubt in my mind he'd be a better starter for them than Deuce McAllister.  Regardless, Watters can still play so I think he will play, especially when you consider all the injuries in the league these days.  If he does start somewhere, he's a heck of a #5 RB. 

I thought seriously about all other positions here accept for PK and DT but I think I'll still be able to address all those the next 3 rounds. 

9.07 RB Rickey Watters

By Guest Brian Roberson of Dr Football

Watters is a better running back right now than Emmitt Smith.  That's not to say that Watters was on par with Smith over the past 10 years.  But in my opinion, Watters has a skill set better than that of Emmitt in 2002.  Even though he is a free agent waiting for a team to pony up some dough, Watters will be very productive once he's signed.  

The guy can catch the ball and he's not afraid to carry between the tackles.  And for all of you out there that really think Watters will be retiring rather than suiting up in '02, just remember this.  He's not the most qualified guy to be in the broadcast booth.  He makes my All-Interview team right along side Rickey Henderson, Evander Holyfield, and Jason White Chocolate Williams.  In other words, stick to carrying the rock Ricky...at least for another year.

9.08 WR Travis Taylor
By Chris Rito of FF  Mastermind
and Carlos Panizo of STATS, Inc.

For all those staunch believers in the "3rd-year WR breakout" theory, this pick is right up your alley! While WR Travis Taylor has only shown erratic flashes of brilliance in his first two years in the NFL, it has been enough to tell us that this kid can play. What a tremendous athlete! Yeah, he only has 70 catches in his 20 starts (24 games) but he has looked great doing that.

This year the Ravens will also have to rely on Taylor a lot more than in the past. First, the defense is being totally retooled and they will no longer be able to rely on a "3-yards-and-a-cloud-of-dust" offense. While they will certainly feature Jamal Lewis (if they can), the weakening of the defense will force them to put the ball in the air more in 2002. Secondly, the Ravens have lost their top two receivers from the recent years, as Qadry Ismail is "manning" the WR#2 slot in Indy (groan) and Shannon Sharpe has returned to the Rocky Mountains to finish his career. The only other WR with any significant experience is Brandon Stokely, and he is not a feature WR caliber guy. Finally, the young QB will need a solid and trusted target out wide, and the 6'1" 200lb Taylor fits the bill.

We expect Taylor to really come into his own in 2002. He was drafted this high in the last two previous FAD's, and with the augmenting factors in his favor this year, we feel he is a worthy risk at this point in the draft, especially with two established and consistent veteran WRs already on the roster. This will be a classic middle-round, risk/reward pick that would make us a real FAD title contender if it pans out as expected.

9.08 WR Travis Taylor 
By Guest Richard Harris of BTGSports.com

WR Travis Taylor, the 10th overall selection of the 2000 draft, has been a disappointment thus far.  In his first two seasons in the league, he has less than 900 total receiving yards.  The positives are that young receivers often blossom in their third and fourth seasons, and as the Baltimore roster stands, Taylor should be the team's No. 1 receiver.  However, the Ravens have been gutted by offseason moves designed to create salary-cap room, and his supporting cast, including the unproven third-year QB Chris Redman, is less than optimal to say the least.  In addition, the club is trying to sign a veteran free agent wideout, with Antonio Freeman being at the top of the wish list.  

If the team goes into the season with its current set of wideouts and Taylor stays healthy, he should have a fair amount of success, finishing with roughly 900-1,000 yards and 6-8 touchdowns.  On the other hand, if the Ravens add Freeman or another experienced receiver, such as Keenan McCardell or Michael Westbrook, Taylor's fantasy value would likely be marginal. 

9.09 WR Joey Galloway
By Shannon O'Leary of FanEx

This pick is pretty much just a gut feeling. Hopefully it's not the two breakfast burritos I just had. WR Joey Galloway has not performed for a few years now. First he held out with the Seahawks, and then he moved to the Cowboys. You really can't expect much from a receiver who changes teams for a couple of years.

Galloway has plenty of speed and talent. He just has to keep his head on strait and get the opportunities to score. One thing of great concern is the quarterback situation in Dallas.

I decided to overlook this as I couldn't name a stud QB that had thrown to Galloway in Seattle. If he can pull it together, then 900-1000 yds are quite possible. Hopefully he will also add between 7 and 10 TDs.

I was looking at Galloway and about 4 other receivers at the 9:01. Travis Taylor was one of them. Looking back I am glad I made the trade with Kellogg and still got one of the guys I was looking at.


9.09 WR Joey Galloway

By Terry Martin

I like this selection for a different reason than most. Actually, I like what Shannon did here more than the player he claimed. The FanEx member took a bold step with selecting an fairly unpopular player as his WR3. While Galloway could easily out do the prior half dozen WRs taken, he is not expected to.. except by the drafter. 

The reason so many of us view this draft is to get analysis and alternate ideas on when and why to draft a guy. It's a plus to know that someone likes this Cowboy and values him on his roster. 

9.10 QB Mark Brunnell
By David Dodds of Footballguys.com

If you had the choice between paying equal value between the following two players, who would you choose?

Player A:
3,828 pass yds, 27 pass TDs
231 rush yards, 2 rush TDs

Player B:
4,069 pass yds, 27 pass TDs
445 rush yds, 7 rush TDs

This is a no-brainer right?  Player B regardless of scoring system is clearly the better player besting Player A in every category except passing TDs (tied him).

With the selection of Mark Brunell, we just landed player B.  Do I think Mark will pass for over 4,000 yards.  No way.  But Kordell Stewart, Jay Fiedler and Mark Brunell combined did just that last season.  In fact they put up Player B's numbers after choosing their best games collectively.

Using the pick value calculator at Footballguys.com, the value of picks 8.01, 8.09 and 9.10 = the value of the QB closest to the 4.09 pick.  That Player is Rich Gannon selected at 5.03.  And his stats?  Why he is Player A of course.

In Stewart, Fiedler and Brunell I get three QBs not in danger of losing their respective jobs.  I also get three players that tend to have a few big games each year and are generally considered erratic as fantasy scorers.

But together I get a player likely better than Rich Gannon and with substantially less injury risk.  This was my strategy going into this draft and it has fallen into place quite nicely.

My strategy to trade down in this round netted me the player I wanted (after I lost the chance to get Freddie Jones or Chad Lewis) and secured me an additional pick in the 12th round too.

9.10 QB Mark Brunnell

By Guest Jym Hansen of Komments.com

If you doubt QBs Stewart or Fiedler, you have a good backup.  Many may be wondering how the hyped Brunell could fall this far.  He is in the right place.  When you examine Brunell, you find two things.  He is a streaky player.  He will play lights out for three games at the beginning of every season.  It is a roller coaster ride from there out.  The second is injuries.  This is not the guy you want as your starter.  However, Dodds picked up a good backup.

 

Trading down netted a great result.  Erratic is an understatement for Brunell.  He is up and down and injured much of the time.  This is the place to risk a pick or two.  Brunell will not pass like he used to and will be hurt more this season.  He is not a player that comes without baggage, but when he is three deep you can’t argue that.


9.11 WR Peerless Price
By William Del Pilar | Ryan Bonini of KFFL

We traded back with several players in mind that we felt would fall to us at this position and were delighted to see our top rated wide receiver (WRs still left) still on the board. Bills’ WR Peerless Price was still on the board as expected as well as some of the other players we had targeted. In essence, our earlier wheeling-and-dealing is playing out as we had hoped ... at least for now.

Price is entering his fourth-year in the NFL, which is a time period where many receivers have their “break out” seasons (years 3/4). Price started to make strides in that direction last year, with 55 receptions for 895 yards and 7 TDs, positioning him in the top-25 of FAD scoring and actually ahead of No. 1 Bills receiver Eric Moulds. This was accomplished on a very bad Buffalo team that had musical QBs most of the season. This year, Price is going to be on a much better team with stability at quarterback in new Bills’ starter Drew Bledsoe.

While Eric Moulds gets all of the attention in Buffalo based off of past seasons, Price quietly continues to improve each season. He’s improved in almost every category each of the past three years, with his receptions, yardage and touchdowns continuing to go up. With Bledsoe entering into the picture, Price will have just as good of a chance to become his favorite receiver as Moulds does because both receivers are new to Bledsoe and the Bills are now working in a new offense under Kevin Gilbride’s direction. Furthermore, Price is entering the final year of his contract with the team and will be looking to cash in at the end of the season. While the Bills drafted WR Josh Reed earlier this year, Reed is going to take some time to pick up the NFL game and won't realistically have a chance to push for a starting job this season. History bears this out with rookie wideouts but when you factor in the type of offensive schemes, coordinator Kevin Gilbride uses and it's a high learning curve for rookie wideouts.

Price (5’11”, 190 lbs.) doesn't have great size but is becoming a very steady playmaker in the Buffalo offense. In 2001, he had three games with better than 100-yards receiving and found the end zone in 7 of 16 games (44%).  Playing in the split-end receiver position, he not only has the ability to go deep, he can also work the intermediate to longer routes over the middle and on the sidelines. While Moulds’ production has declined, he still typically lands the opponent’s best cover corner, allowing Price to work in one-on-one coverage. Furthermore, the Bills’ new offensive scheme will allow them to take pressure off of Price through double tight end sets, which forces opposing secondaries to commit extra safety help. Also, FB Larry Centers always deserves a lot of attention in the flats as well. In his fourth-year, Price should be ready to take his game to the next level and having single coverage will only better his chances.

At this point in the draft, we wanted to add our No. 3 receiver as an upside-loaded, yet somewhat proven, weapon. We feel we found that in Price and feel our key positions have been filled and are now willing to look at depth and riskier picks in order to protect our starters and find that hidden gem.

9.11 WR Peerless Price

By Guest Craig Brye

Having reached the portion of the draft where most teams are selecting boom or bust choices and still several rounds away from beginning a serious kicker or defense run, WR Peerless Price has to be viewed as a spectacular pick.  

It is my guess that Price will fall much further in drafts than he should and my firm belief that he will make people wish they jumped on him sooner.  The bottom line is this guy just doesn't get the respect he deserves. 

In three years in the league, his production has increased in all major categories each year including a 55-catch/895 yds/7 td season last year and saw his YPC average jump to 16.3.  That's pretty darn good numbers for a #3 WR!  To give you an idea of the disparity in respect for Price's production, Eric Moulds only had 12 more receptions, 9 (that's not a typo) more yards, two LESS touchdowns and a lower YPC average than Price and Moulds went in the 4th round!  This was all done with stiffs like Rob Johnson and Alex Van Pelt throwing the pill.  Now we have Drew Bledsoe behind center and we all know he's not afraid of the deep ball. 

I don't think he's on the verge of a breakout season, he had that last year.  You know what kind of steady production you're going to get from Price and the Bills have made moves that can only add to his upside.  When you look at the players selected before Price going all the way back to the beginning of round 7 such as Galloway, Taylor, Alexander, Ward, Ismail, Gardner, Conway and Muhammad, you'd be hard pressed to say with confidence any one of them is going to outperform Price.  As I write this I'm beginning to see Peerless Price at 9.11 for what he truly is...a STEAL.

9.12 WR Koren Robinson
By Emil Kadlec of FF Pro Forecast

Seahawk coach Mike Holmgren is convinced that WR Koren Robinson will quickly establish himself as the kind of weapon the coach envisioned before making the former N.C. State star a first-round draft pick last April. 

"He's a very talented you man who came into camp last year with a big hamstring problem and never got his legs underneath him so he couldn't show everyone the way he can play," Holmgren recently explained. "He came into mini-camp this year on fire. He really needed to let it heal and rest it and he really came in on fire. ..." In addition to hamstring problems, Robinson also battled maturity problems at times. "He was the youngest guy in the draft last year and I wanted to keep in the lineup last year to give him an extra year to mature," said Holmgren. "I think he'll bust out this year and if he does, he'll be a special player."

9.12 WR Koren Robinson 

By Guest Mike Krueger of FFToday.com

The decision by Mike Holmgren to go with Trent Dilfer as his starting QB should help 2nd-year wideout Koren Robinson elevate his game. Young receivers having to cope with a revolving door at Quarterback typically leads to fantasy mediocrity and Robinson fit the profile during his rookie season... 39 catches, 536 yds and 1 TD.

Also, Seattle has established an identity running the ball with Shaun Alexander and he will continue be option number one for the Holmgren offense. This should help keep the pressure of the passing game allowing #1 WR Darrell Jackson and Robinson to further establish themselves in the offense. Jackson will continue to get the majority of looks but with another year of maturity and stability at the QB position, Robinson should improve on his numbers from a year ago... possibly into the 700-yd, 5 TD range, giving Emil a viable option during bye weeks or a nice replacement should an injury occur to Keyshawn or Chambers.

 

 


  Commissioner: Tony Holm  
        Webmaster: TC Cannon  
 
 

TC  Cannon

FanExFootball.com is not in any way affiliated with, endorsed or 
licensed by the National Football League, any NFL team or NFLPA member.
            © Copyright 1998-2006 by FanExFootball. All rights reserved.